Call for Article Reviewers
We welcome researchers with expertise in Earth and Planetary Sciences and Green Sciences, and a proven scientific publication record, to take part in the SGEM peer-review process.
The Vienna GREEN scientific topics cover sustainable resource use, water and ecosystems, clean energy, environmental protection, green technologies and interdisciplinary research for a sustainable future. Explore the conference topics and sections →
Apply as an article reviewer → · EPS reviewer directory →
The common SWS review process and criteria are reproduced below. View the official current version
Double-Blind Peer Review
Reviewers are matched based on:
- Area of expertise
- Topical relevance
- Reviewer availability and workflow balance
The entire process is double-blind: authors and reviewers remain anonymous to one another, ensuring fairness, impartiality, and objectivity.
Reviewers complete their evaluations directly within AMMS, where they may:
- Submit structured evaluations and recommendations
- Add detailed comments for authors
- Leave confidential notes for the Scientific or Editorial Committee
Evaluation Criteria
- Relevance to the Conference or Journal Scope
- Contribution to the Scientific or Academic Debate
- Clarity of the Research Problem, Aim, and Objectives
- Appropriateness of the Research Methodology
- Standard of English
- Use and Relevance of Keywords
- Appropriate Section or Topic Selection
- Overall Abstract Quality and Impression
- Final Recommendation: Accept / Minor Revisions / Major Revisions / Reject
- Reviewer Comments
Manuscript Review Criteria
- Scientific Merit and Validity
- Clarity of Writing, Structure, and Logical Flow
- Quality and Appropriateness of Figures and Tables
- Relevance and Depth of the Discussion
- Justification of the Conclusions
- Interdisciplinary Relevance and Broader Impact
- Originality and Novelty of the Research
- Final Recommendation: Accept / Accept with Revisions / Reject
- Reviewer Comments
Reviewer responsibilities and publication ethics
Your application expresses your interest; it does not automatically confirm an appointment. Selected researchers receive an invitation from the committee. Complete the official reviewer application →